Combining centuries-old traditional mandala coloring with cutting-edge computing and brain sensing technologies could lead to new ways of helping people achieve mindfulness.
Mandalas are geometric configurations of shapes that have their origins in Buddhist traditions. The coloring of mandala shapes is increasingly popular as a way for people to attempt ‘mindfulness’, a way of being present in the moment, and which has been associated with helping people to improve their mental health and wellbeing.
Human-computer interaction researchers from Lancaster University have developed a new prototype that can monitor people’s brain signals while they are coloring mandalas and produce real-time feedback on a peripheral display to represent levels of mindfulness.
The researchers, who specialize in thinking about how new computing technologies can be designed to help people, believe systems like these could be developed to aid the learning, and training, of focused attention mindfulness techniques and help people deal with stress, depression and other affective health disorders.
In the first part of their study, the researchers interviewed experienced mandala practicioners to find out about the special qualities of mandala coloring, and how they can be used to achieve mindfulness, and based the prototype on their findings.
The prototype, called ‘Anima’, included a tablet device for users to color mandala shapes, a wearable EEG headset that reads wearers’ brain signals, and a second display in the shape of an artists’ palette, that is placed in the user’s periphery.
When users color a digital mandala, using a stylus, on the main display, the EEG headset monitors their brain signals and gages levels of mindfulness. The readings are then represented on the peripheral display as new additional colors, based on four colors selected at the start by the user, but with changes to the saturation and brightness. More subtle colors represented mindfulness periods, with brighter colors representing periods where the user lost focus or became distracted.
The research was supported by AffecTech: Personal Technologies for Affective Health, Innovative Training Network funded through the European Union’s Horizon2020 People Program under Marie Skłodowska-Curie, and led by Professor Corina Sas of Lancaster University’s School of Computing and Communications.
Making sense of EEG data and capturing it effectively through design is not a trivial process. It was important that the colors appearing on the peripheral display, which was decoupled from the main screen, were ambiguous and subtle in order to provide the ability for users to openly monitor their mindfulness but not in a way that distracted their attention from the coloring itself.”
Corina Sas, Professor, School of Computing and Communications, Lancaster University
“The study outcomes suggest two important and previously unrecognised roles of the mandala: capturing emotional memories and reflecting on them. Technology could support both these roles in ways paper-based mandalas are less able to do so. Participants noted they would much prefer to re-engage with their completed mandala at the reflection stage, and that they longed to even recolor them, often in more positive colors after they had reflected and their mental situation had shifted. Technologies would be able to make this more possible.”
Dominic Potts, PhD student and Lancaster University and co-author, added: “By understanding how Anima provides feedback, and reflecting on their coloring session using the data provided by the prototype, people can use these kinds of technologies to help improve their mandala coloring as a focused attention mindfulness practice.”
The study found that many people who use mandala coloring for mindfulness, and to help with their mental health, like to keep their completed mandalas and look back at them as a way of reflecting on how they felt at the time they colored them. This is another area where technology could help.
The research revealed new understanding in a number of additional areas that could help lead to the development of new mindfulness technologies.
“This decoupling of displays with the use of near periphery for real-time monitoring of the activity on the main display is an important design principle that can be beneficial for mindfulness technologies,” Dr Claudia Dauden Roquet, lead author of the study, said. “In addition, there has been little attention within human-computer interaction research looking at mindfulness techniques that use fine motor skills, such as coloring intricate details on mandalas, or meditation beads. Our findings offer new insight into these areas that could also help inspire new classes of mindfulness technologies.
“This can be extended to the design of peripheral visual feedback designs for other types of technologies monitoring mindfulness training on a main display. This could be wristbands on which real-time visuals may appear in random order as subtle indication of one’s mindfulness state, or as colors on embedded in objects, such as backlit mouse pads.”
Roquet, C. D., et al. (2021) Exploring Anima: a brain–computer interface for peripheral materialization of mindfulness states during mandala coloring. Human–Computer Interaction. doi.org/10.1080/07370024.2021.1968864.